Premium Bonds vs ISA: Which Is Better for Your Savings in 2025?
Choosing between Premium Bonds and ISAs is one of the most common savings decisions UK savers face. This comprehensive guide compares Premium Bonds against Cash ISAs, Stocks & Shares ISAs, and Lifetime ISAs to help you make the right choice for your money.
Contents
Quick Comparison: Premium Bonds vs ISAs
| Feature | Premium Bonds | Cash ISA | S&S ISA | Lifetime ISA |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Returns | 3.6% average (variable) | 4-5% (guaranteed) | Variable (market-dependent) | Variable + 25% bonus |
| Tax Status | Tax-free | Tax-free | Tax-free | Tax-free |
| Annual Limit | £50,000 total | £20,000/year | £20,000/year | £4,000/year |
| Access | 3 working days | Instant to fixed | Usually 2-5 days | Age 60 or first home |
| Capital Risk | None | None | Yes (can lose money) | Yes (if invested) |
| Best For | Higher-rate taxpayers, beyond ISA limit | Guaranteed returns | Long-term growth | First home or retirement |
Premium Bonds vs Cash ISA
This is the most direct comparison since both are low-risk, tax-free savings options. Here's how they stack up:
Returns Comparison
🎟️ Premium Bonds
- Rate: 3.6% prize fund rate
- Nature: Variable prizes (£25 to £1M)
- Guarantee: No guaranteed return
- Reality: Most holders get less than 3.6%
💰 Cash ISA
- Rate: 4-5% (as of January 2025)
- Nature: Guaranteed interest
- Guarantee: Fixed or variable, but predictable
- Reality: You get exactly what's promised
💡 The Verdict: Cash ISA vs Premium Bonds
For most savers: Cash ISA wins with guaranteed 4-5% returns. Use your £20,000 ISA allowance first before considering Premium Bonds.
Exception: If you've already maxed your ISA and are a higher-rate taxpayer, Premium Bonds beat taxable savings accounts.
Example: £10,000 Investment Over 1 Year
| Product | Rate | Return | Certainty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash ISA | 4.5% | £450 | Guaranteed |
| Premium Bonds (average) | 3.6% | £360 | Expected (varies) |
| Premium Bonds (lucky) | 5%+ | £500+ | Possible but unlikely |
| Premium Bonds (unlucky) | 0-2% | £0-200 | Also possible |
Premium Bonds vs Stocks & Shares ISA
Comparing Premium Bonds to a Stocks & Shares ISA is like comparing apples to oranges — they serve very different purposes. Here's when each makes sense:
✅ Choose Premium Bonds When:
- You need absolute capital security (no risk of loss)
- You'll need the money within 5 years
- You've already used your ISA allowance
- Market volatility causes you anxiety
- You want a "set and forget" savings option
✅ Choose Stocks & Shares ISA When:
- You're investing for 5+ years (ideally 10+)
- You want to maximise long-term growth potential
- You can tolerate seeing your balance fluctuate
- You're building retirement savings
- You understand that short-term losses are normal
Historical Returns Comparison
Over the long term, stock markets have historically returned around 7-10% annually (before inflation). However, this comes with significant volatility:
- 2008 crash: Markets fell 40%+ in one year
- 2020 COVID: 30%+ drop in weeks, then recovered
- 2022: Both stocks and bonds fell significantly
⚠️ Important Consideration
Many financial advisers argue that for younger savers, using the ISA allowance on low-risk investments (gilts, money market funds) within a S&S ISA is preferable to leaving the allowance unused. The tax wrapper has long-term value even if you're risk-averse.
Premium Bonds vs Lifetime ISA
Lifetime ISAs (LISAs) are specialised accounts for first-time home buyers or retirement savings. Here's how they compare:
Key Differences
| Feature | Premium Bonds | Lifetime ISA |
|---|---|---|
| Government Bonus | None | 25% on contributions (up to £1,000/year) |
| Annual Limit | N/A (£50k total) | £4,000/year |
| Withdrawal | Any time, penalty-free | 25% penalty if not for home/retirement |
| Age Limit | 16+ to hold, any age to buy (via adult) | 18-39 to open, 18-50 to contribute |
💡 The Verdict: LISA vs Premium Bonds
For first-time home buyers: Lifetime ISA wins hands-down. The 25% bonus is an instant guaranteed return that Premium Bonds can't match.
For flexible savings: Premium Bonds win because there's no penalty for withdrawing for any reason.
Do Premium Bonds Count Towards ISA Allowance?
No, Premium Bonds do not count towards your £20,000 ISA allowance.
Premium Bonds are a completely separate product from ISAs. They're run by NS&I (National Savings & Investments) and have their own rules:
- Maximum holding: £50,000 per person
- Minimum purchase: £25
- No annual contribution limit
- Separate from ISA limits entirely
This means you can hold the maximum £50,000 in Premium Bonds AND contribute £20,000 to ISAs each year. They complement each other rather than competing for the same allowance.
Which Is Better: ISA or Premium Bonds?
The best choice depends on your circumstances. Here's a decision framework:
Use ISAs First When:
- You haven't used your £20,000 annual ISA allowance
- You want guaranteed returns
- You're building long-term wealth
- You're eligible for a Lifetime ISA bonus
Use Premium Bonds When:
- You've already maxed your ISA allowance
- You're a higher-rate (40%+) taxpayer with savings beyond ISA limits
- You enjoy the excitement of monthly prize draws
- You want ultra-flexible access to your savings
- You're saving for children (Premium Bonds can be held from birth)
Optimal Strategy for Most People
Recommended Approach
- First: Max out any employer pension match (free money)
- Second: Build emergency fund (3-6 months expenses)
- Third: Use ISA allowance (Cash or S&S based on goals)
- Fourth: Consider Premium Bonds for additional savings
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Premium Bonds better than an ISA?
Generally no — Cash ISAs offer guaranteed returns of 4-5% compared to Premium Bonds' variable 3.6% average. However, Premium Bonds become attractive once you've used your ISA allowance, especially for higher-rate taxpayers.
Can I have both Premium Bonds and an ISA?
Yes! There's no restriction on holding both. You can have up to £50,000 in Premium Bonds AND contribute £20,000 to ISAs annually. Many savers use both as part of a diversified savings strategy.
Is it better to have a Lifetime ISA or Premium Bonds?
For first-time home buyers or retirement savings, the Lifetime ISA's 25% government bonus makes it the clear winner. Premium Bonds are better for flexible savings you might need for other purposes.
What happens to my ISA if I move abroad?
You can keep existing ISAs but generally can't add new money while non-UK resident. Premium Bonds can be held by UK residents and many overseas residents, making them more flexible for expats.
Should I transfer my ISA to Premium Bonds?
Generally no — you'd lose the tax-free ISA wrapper and get lower returns. Only consider this if you need flexible access and have already maxed your current year's ISA allowance.
Use Our Comparison Tools
Still not sure which is right for you? Use our free calculators to compare options based on your specific situation:
Considering alternatives?
I use Trading 212 for both their Cash ISA and commission-free investing. It's a flexible platform whether you want savings or investments.
New users get £25 cash via my referral link. You'll need to open an Invest account, verify ID, fund it, get a T212 card and make 3 payments of £5+.
Disclosure: I receive a bonus too. Capital at risk when investing.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Returns and rates mentioned are accurate as of January 2025 but may change. Consider your personal circumstances and consult a financial advisor for personalized guidance.